Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk

I've been substituting half-and-half for milk in my Kraft Mac and Cheese for a bit of extra creaminess. How far can I take this? from Cooking

Macaroni and cheese is one of the ultimate comfort foods. Luckily, there are many different alternatives to milk to use in macaroni and cheese when no milk is to be found. Learn about 16 substitutes for milk in mac and cheese here!

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk

Jump to:
  • The Best Mac and Cheese
  • What Can You Substitute for Milk in Macaroni and Cheese?
  • 1. Non-Dairy Milk Substitutes
  • 2. Sour Cream
  • 3. Heavy Cream
  • 4. Yogurt
  • 5. Half and Half
  • 6. Coconut Cream
  • 7. Cream Cheese
  • 8. Butter
  • 9. Broth
  • 10. Powdered Milk
  • 11. Evaporated Milk
  • 12. Goat Milk
  • 13. Shredded Cheese 
  • 14. Oil 
  • 15. Roux
  • 16. Water
  • You Might Also Like
  • 💬 Comments

My kiddos love their macaroni and cheese, so I figured it high-time I write about all the milk substitutes I've used over the years when making their favorite creamy comfort dish!

Whether you are on a dairy-free or vegan diet and looking for alternatives, or simply ran out of milk, we've got you covered! We'll tell you what to use in store-bought or homemade mac and cheese when there is no milk to be found. Enjoy!

The Best Mac and Cheese

When it comes to purchasing macaroni and cheese in a box, we love our Annie's products! Whether diet-free or on a gluten-free or vegan diet (or both!), Annie's offers just about every type of mac and cheese you can think of! My kids are partial to the white cheddar shells.

What Can You Substitute for Milk in Macaroni and Cheese?

1. Non-Dairy Milk Substitutes

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk
Dairy-free milk.

Oat milk and canned coconut milk are the creamiest dairy alternatives, but rice milk, almond milk, cashew milk, soy milk or hemp seed milk will get the job done, too. Use the same amount you would use when using conventional dairy milk.

2. Sour Cream

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk
Sour cream.

Regular or plant-based sour cream makes a suitable replacement for milk in mac and cheese recipes. Use sour cream just as you would milk in a 1:1 ratio. It adds slightly tangy flavor notes that are nonetheless delicious!

3. Heavy Cream

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk
Heavy cream (aka whipping cream).

If you have some heavy whipping cream on hand, you can certainly throw it into macaroni and cheese for very similar results to milk. In fact, you'll find your mac and cheese to be even creamier.

4. Yogurt

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk
Yogurt.

You can use conventional plain yogurt or a plant-based yogurt like cashew yogurt to replace milk in mac and cheese dishes. Use in a 1:1 ratio. Plain Greek yogurt produces the creamiest and tastiest results.

5. Half and Half

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk
Half and half.

Do you take your coffee with half and half? You're in luck! You can use half and half just as you would milk when preparing macaroni and cheese.

6. Coconut Cream

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk
Coconut cream.

Have a can of coconut cream on hand? Coconut cream is creamier and has a higher fat content than its milk counterpart, making it a great vegan milk substitute in mac and cheese recipes.

7. Cream Cheese

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk
Cream cheese.

Cream cheese makes for a super tasty end result when used as a replacement for milk in mac and cheese! Use in a 1:1 ratio, just as you would milk. This substitute results in a super decadent comfort dish!

8. Butter

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk
Butter.

If you are out of milk and making a box of macaroni and cheese, you can simply throw in extra butter to get the taste and texture that mac and cheese demands.

9. Broth

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk
Vegetable broth.

Vegetable broth makes a great milk substitute in mac and cheese in a pinch! Use ever so slightly less than you would with milk, to maintain a creamy consistency.

10. Powdered Milk

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk
Powdered milk.

Both nonfat dry milk or coconut milk powder can be used to replace milk in mac and cheese. Simply stir the powder in for slightly thicker, yet still delicious results.

11. Evaporated Milk

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk
Evaporated milk.

Have a can of evaporated milk sitting in the pantry? It can be used in a pinch when no milk is to be found! Use in 1:1 ratio, just as you would whole milk or skim milk. Note: not to be confused with condensed milk which is far too sweet for mac and cheese!

12. Goat Milk

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk
Goat milk.

You can certainly use goat milk instead of cow's milk in your mac and cheese dishes! Use exactly the same way.

13. Shredded Cheese 

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk

If you do not have milk, but have some cheese in the fridge, you can throw a handful of the shredded variety into the pot when cooking macaroni and cheese for some creaminess that otherwise would be missing sans milk. Cheddar cheese, colby jack cheese, mozzarella cheese and parmesan cheese work great.

14. Oil 

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk
Oil.

Use half the amount of milk you would normally use in macaroni and cheese in oil instead for a silky smooth cheese sauce in your mac. Olive oil and avocado oil work well.

15. Roux

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk
Roux.

A roux is a flour and fat combo used to thicken sauces, soups, you name it. To make a roux, heat one tablespoon of flour (regular or gluten-free) and one tablespoon of fat like butter or oil over medium heat. Stir constantly for 2-3 minutes, or until the flour taste has disappeared. Mix the roux into mac and cheese just as you would milk. Needless to say, this results in a thicker macaroni and cheese, but it works!

16. Water

Mac and cheese with half and half instead of milk
Water.

Yep, water! This is certainly the most budget-friendly option (obviously). I've made mac and cheese with water and without both milk and butter. It gets the job done in a pinch!

I hope you now know what to use instead of milk when making mac and cheese! If you enjoyed this post, I would appreciate your support by following me on Instagram. Thank you!

Is half and half good in mac and cheese?

Butter:is always essential in Southern Mac and Cheese recipes. It adds richness and additional fat. Heavy Cream/Half and Half:For liquids to create additional creaminess, both heavy whipping cream (which also has butter) and half and half are used.

Can I substitute half and half for milk?

Half and half can easily be used in place of whole milk with the addition of a little water. Combine ¾ cup half and half and ¼ cup water for every cup of whole milk you're substituting. 1 cup whole milk: combine ¾ cup half and half and ¼ cup water.

What can I substitute for milk in mac n cheese?

Milk Substitutes for Mac n Cheese. If the reason that you're making the substitute is just because you don't have milk or aren't able to obtain milk, then sour cream, cream cheese, butter or margarine are all good substitutes for milk in your mac and cheese.

Can you add half and half to box mac and cheese?

It really helps it taste extra creamy and not just cheesy. Half and Half: Adding half and half to the macaroni does so much in amping up the creamy factor. If you don't have half and half, I'd recommend using whole milk.