Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?
lamilou said:

edward thought that it may be because bella's mind is on a different "frequency". like he can read people minds' who are in AM but hers is in FM frequency. but afterwards we discover in breaking dawn that bella has a special ability, that of a shield. she can shield and thus protect her mind and thoughts from others. it only works with everything mental though,not physical. therefore edward,demetri,jane,aro can't enter her mind.

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?
Makala125 said:

It is because Bella has something called a sheld which she finds out when she is a vampire.

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?
Impulse85 said:

She's a sheild, that's what we find out in Breaking Dawn, but as far as I'm concerned, she doesn't have a mind to read. I mean she can't really seem to actually think for herself, or think of anyting outside of Edward...her character really sets women back a good hundred years. I really wish Jane would have been able to inflict some pain on her.

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?
warewolf913 said:

becuase she has protection powers when she becomes a bloodsucker. all of thier powers show earily on before the change if anymore expliantion is needed re-read twilight and breaking dawn.

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?
TaintedDreamz said:

She has the power of a 'Shield like force.' It protects her and people around her. Although while she is a human she doesn't fully know this because she can't actually do anything with it. It is more of a supernatural power when she actually becomes a Vampire.

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?
BuffyFaithFan1 said:

Cause Bella has a shield power thing like a repeller and it repells everybody's power...includign Edwards!

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?
BABIIat said:

Edward can't see through Bella's thoughts because Bella's got dis specail shield dat can protect her thoughts nd protect her from other vampire's special powers

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?
mizzfan1234 said:

i think that edward cant read her mind because
he cannot control his feelings around her like in the first book. also because bella cannot control hers so lots of other people dont feel the same way about him so he can read anyone elses mind.

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?
twilight4 said:

THIS CONTAINS SPIOLERS FROM BREAKING DAWN!! the reason is that bella was meant to be a vamp and her gift when she turns into one is that she has a shield which can protect people and that is why he cant read her mind.

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?
JKwillieluvr said:

The reason Edward can't read Bella's mind is that she is a sheild which you don't find out till breaking dawn. Even as a human she is a shield so she is pretty powerful.

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?
tls411 said:

I think the reason Edward can't read Bellas mind is because she is an angel of God put on earth to protect humans but doesn't no it yet that is why her name is "Bella" from the name Isabella meaning devoted to God, and this is why she is protected from the vamps and the werewolves, she has here own power she just isn't in tune with her power yet, but I think will figure it out.

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?
huskiefan said:

he cant read her mind because bells human i think

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?
XXCissyXX said:

:D i think it's because the story wouldn't be so cool and so interesting if he could :D

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?
chris2010_2010 said:

He cant read her mind b/c she is a shield when she is turned... Just like all the others cant use their powers on her except for jasper and renesmee.

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?
shaquilla said:

I think he cant read her mind because she is not the tepical girl; she is very different and he cant read her mind because you cant read your true loves mind........

Why Can Edward read Bellas mind when she was human?

Why couldn't Edward read Bella's mind when she was human?

Bella's gift is her very powerful shield – one that has been growing and working without her knowing since she was born. Because of her shield, she is protected from powers of the mind – that means that Edward (and Aro) can't read her thoughts, Kate can't shock her, and Jane can't cause her pain.

How did Bella let Edward read her mind?

At the end of Breaking Dawn, Bella removes her shield to allow Edward to read her mind. She describes this as being much more difficult than pushing it out, as it struggles to protect her and it takes all of her concentration to make it disappear altogether.

Could Edward read minds as a human?

Edward had been keen at reading people from his human life, which is why he manifests the talent to read people's thoughts as a vampire.

Why can Jasper Control Bella's mood but Edward can't read her mind?

Edwards power affects the mind, Jasper affects the body. He physically makes you more relaxed or excited or whatever he wants. Bella is a shield which means she is unaffected by any mental powers like mind reading or Jane's pain powers.