All-Pro: 2003 (AP, PFWA, SN) · 2004 (AP, PFWA, SN) · 2005 (AP, PFWA, SN) · 2008 (AP, PFWA) · 2009 (AP) · 2012 (AP, PFWA, SN, ESPN) · 2013 (AP, PFWA, SN, SI, ESPN)
All-Pro Second Team: 1999 (AP) · 2000 (AP) · 2006 (AP)
All-AFC: 1999 (PW) · 2003 (PW) · 2004 (PW) · 2005 (PW) · 2006 (PW) · 2008 (PW) · 2009 (PW) · 2012 (PW) · 2013 (PFWA)
(14) – 2000, 2001, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010*, 2011, 2013, 2014*, 2015*
* Did not play
In the NFL Record Book (at time of his retirement following 2015 season)
· [1st] Most Passing Yards, Career – 71,940
· [1st] Most Passing Yards, Season – 5,477 (2013)
· [1st] Most Games, 400 or More Yards Passing – 14
· [1st] Most Touchdown Passes, Career – 539
· [1st] Most Touchdown Passes, Season – 55 (2013)
· [1st] Most Games, Four or More Touchdown Passes, Career – 35
· [1st] Most Games, Four or More Touchdown Passes, Season – 9 (2013)
· [1st] Most Consecutive Games, Four or More Touchdown Passes – 5 (2004)
· [Tied for 1st] Most Games, 400 or More Yards Passing, Season – 4 (2013)
· [Tied for 1st] Most Seasons, Leading the League, Passing Touchdowns – 4
· [Tied for 1st] Most Touchdown Passes, Rookie Season – 26 (1998)
· [Tied for 1st] Most Touchdown Passes, Game – 7 (vs. Baltimore, Sept. 5, 2013)
· [2nd] Most Consecutive Seasons Leading League, Passer Rating – 3 (2004-06)
· [2nd] Highest Passer Rating, Season – 121.1 (2004)
· [2nd] Most Passes Attempted, Career – 9,380
· [2nd] Most Passes Completed, Career – 6,125
· [2nd] Most Seasons, 3,000 or More Yards Passing – 16
· [2nd] Most Games, 300 or More Yards Passing – 93
· [2nd] Most Games, 300 or More Yards Passing, Season – 12 (2013)
· [Tied for 2nd] Most Games, Four or More Touchdown Passes, Season – 6 (2004)
· [3rd] Most Passes Attempted, Season – 679 (2010)
· [3rd] Most Passes Completed, Season – 450 (2010, 2013)
· [3rd] Most Consecutive Passes Completed, Game – 23 (vs. Detroit (6), Dec. 14, 2008 - vs. Jacksonville (17), Dec. 18, 2008)
· [3rd] Most Consecutive Games, 300 or More Yards Passing, Season – 7 (2013)
· [3rd] Most Touchdown Passes, Season – 49 (2004)
· [3rd] Most Consecutive Games with a Touchdown Pass – 51 (2010-14)
· [Tied for 3rd] Most Seasons Leading League, Passer Rating – 3
· [Tied for 3rd] Most Seasons Leading League, Passing Attempts – 3
· [Tied for 3rd] Most Seasons Leading League, Pass Completions – 4
· [5th] Highest Career Passer Rating – 96.5
Super Bowl Records
· [2nd] Most Passes Attempted, Career – 155
· [2nd] Most Passes Completed, Career – 103
· [2nd] Most Passes Completed, Game – 34 (vs. Seattle, SB XLVIII)
· [Tied for 2nd] Most Fumbles, Career – 4
· [Tied for 2nd] Most Fumbles, Game – 2 (vs. Carolina, SB 50)
· [3rd] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Career – 66.5 (4 games)
Postseason Records
· [2nd] Most Passes Attempted, Career – 1,027
· [2nd] Most Passes Completed, Career – 649
· [2nd] Most Passing Yards, Career – 7,339
· [2nd] Most Games, 300 or More Yards Passing – 9
· [Tied for 2nd] Most Touchdown Passes, Game – 5 (vs. Denver, 2003)
· [3rd] Highest Pass Gain, Game – 14.50 (vs. Denver, 2003)
· [Tied for 3rd] Most Consecutive Games, 300 or More Yards Passing – 2 (2003, 2007-08, 2009)
· [Tied for 3rd] Most Consecutive Games with a Touchdown Passes – 13
Pro Bowl Records
· [1st] Most Passes Attempted, Career – 196
· [1st] Most Passes Attempted, Game – 41 (2004)
· [1st] Most Passes Completed, Career – 115
· [1st] Most Passes Completed, Game – 22 (2004)
· [1st] Most Passing Yards, Career – 1,551
· [1st] Most Passing Yards, Game – 342 (2004)
· [1st] Most Touchdown Passes, Career – 15
· [1st] Most Passes Intercepted, Career – 9
· [Tied for 1st] Most Fumble Recoveries, Career – 3
· [Tied for 2nd] Most Games Played – 11
· [Tied for 2nd] Most Touchdown Passes, Game – 3 (2004, 2005)
· [Tied for 3rd] Most Passes Intercepted, Game – 3 (2006)
Colts records held by Peyton
(Records through the 2011 season, Peyton’s final season with Indianapolis)
· [1st] Most Games – 208
· [1st] Most Consecutive Games – 208
· [1st] Most Passes Attempted, Career – 7,210
· [1st] Most Passes Attempted, Season – 679 (2010)
· [1st] Most Passes Attempted, Rookie Season – 575 (1998)
· [1st] Most Consecutive Seasons Leading Team in Attempts/Completions – 13
· [1st] Most Games 40 or More Pass Attempts (59)
· [1st] Most Consecutive Games with a Pass Attempt – 208
· [1st] Most Consecutive Seasons Leading Team in Attempts/Completions – 13
· [1st] Most Passes Completed, Career – 4,682
· [1st] Most Passes Completed, Season – 450 (2010)
· [1st] Most Passes Completed, Rookie Season – 326 (1998)
· [1st] Most Passes Completed, Game – 40 (at Houston, Sept. 12, 2010)
· [1st] Most Passes Completed, Rookie Game – 30 (vs. New England, Nov. 1, 1998)
· [1st] Most Consecutive Completions – 23 (vs. Detroit/at Jacksonville, Dec. 14-18, 2008)
· [1st] Most Games with a Completion – 208
· [1st] Most Games with 20 or More Completions in a Game – 153
· [1st] Most Consecutive Games with 20 or More Completions in a Game – 14 (2010)
· [1st] Most Seasons, 150 or More Completions – 13
· [1st] Most Consecutive Seasons, 150 or More Completions – 13
· [1st] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Career – 64.9
· [1st] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Game – 87.5 (vs. Tennessee, Dec. 30, 2010 – 14-16)
· [1st] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Season – 68.8 (2009)
· [1st] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Rookie Season – 56.7 (1998)
· [1st] Most Passing Yards, Career – 54,828
· [1st] Most Passing Yards, Season – 4,700 (2010)
· [1st] Most Passing Yards, Rookie Season – 3,739 (1998)
· [1st] Most Passing Yards, Game – 472 (at Kansas City, Oct. 31, 2004)
· [1st] Most Seasons Leading Team in Passing Yards and TDs – 13
· [1st] Most Consecutive Seasons Leading Team in Passing Yards and TDs – 13
· [1st] Most Consecutive Seasons, 2,000 or More Passing Yards – 13
· [1st] Most Games, 300 or More Yards Passing – 63
· [1st] Most Games, 300 or More Yards Passing, Season – 9 (2009)
· [1st] Most Games, 300 or More Yards Passing, Rookie Season – 4 (1998)
· [1st] Most Consecutive Games, 300 or More Passing Yards – 5 (2009)
· [1st] Most Touchdown Passes, Career – 399
· [1st] Most Touchdown Passes, Season – 49 (2004)
· [1st] Most Touchdown Passes, Rookie Season – 26 (1998)
· [1st] Most Touchdown Passes, Game – 6 (at New Orleans, Sept. 28, 2003; at Detroit, Nov. 25, 2004)
· [1st] Most Games with a Touchdown Pass – 182
· [1st] Most Games with a Touchdown Pass, Season – 15 (1998, 2000, 2002, 2004, 2006)
· [1st] Most Games with a Touchdown Pass, Rookie Season – 15 (1998)
· [1st] Most Consecutive Games with a Touchdown Pass, Rookie Season – 13 (1998)
· [1st] Most Consecutive Games with Two or More Touchdown Passes – 13 (2004)
· [1st] Highest Touchdown Percentage, Season – 9.86
· [1st] Highest Touchdown Percentage, Game – 24.00 (at New Orleans, Sept. 28, 2003)
· [1st] Most Passing Interceptions, Season – 28 (1998)
· [1st] Most Passing Interceptions, Rookie Season – 28 (1998)
· [1st] Most Passing Interceptions, Game – 6 (at San Diego, Nov. 11, 2007)
· [1st] Highest Passer Rating, Career – 94.9
· [1st] Highest Passer Rating, Season – 121.1 (2004)
· [Tied for 1st] Most Touchdown Passes, Rookie Game – 3 (at San Francisco, Oct. 18, 1998; vs. N.Y. Jets, Nov. 15, 1998; at Kansas City, Oct. 31, 1998; vs. Houston, Nov. 14, 1998)
· [Tied for 1st] Most Seasons, 2,000 or More Passing Yards – 13
· [Tied for 1st] Most Seasons, 200 or More Pass Attempts – 13
· [2nd] Most Seasons – 14
· [2nd] Most Games with a Rushing Attempt – 143
· [2nd] Most Passes Attempted, Season – 591 (2002)
· [2nd] Most Seasons Leading Team in Attempts/Completions – 13
· [2nd] Most Passes Completed, Season – 393 (2009)
· [2nd] Most Passes Completed, Game – 38 (at New England, Nov. 21, 2010)
· [2nd] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Season – 67.6 (2004)
· [2nd] Most Passing Yards, Season – 4,557 (2004)
· [2nd] Most Games, 300 or More Yards Passing, Season – 7 (2010)
· [2nd] Most Touchdown Passes, Season – 33 (2000, 2009, 2010)
· [2nd] Most Consecutive Games with 20 or More Completions in a Game – 12 (2003, 2009)
· [2nd] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Game – 85.3 (at Jacksonville, Dec. 18, 2008 – 29-34)
· [2nd] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Rookie Game – 70.4 (at Atlanta, Dec. 6, 1998)
· [2nd] Most Passing Yards, Game – 440 (vs. Jacksonville, Sept. 25, 2000)
· [2nd] Most Passing Yards, Rookie Game – 357 (at Baltimore, Nov. 29, 1998)
· [2nd] Most Games with a Touchdown Pass, Season – 14 (1999, 2001, 2007, 2008, 2010)
· [2nd] Most Consecutive Games with a Touchdown Pass – 27 (1998-99)
· [1st] Highest Touchdown Percentage – 5.53
· [2nd] Highest Touchdown Percentage, Game – 23.53 (at Baltimore, December 9, 2007)
· [2nd] Highest Touchdown Percentage, Rookie Game – 11.54 (vs. Cincinnati, Dec. 13, 1998)
· [2nd] Highest Passing Average Per Attempt, Career – 7.60
· [2nd] Most Passing Interceptions, Career – 198
· [2nd] Lowest Passing Interception Percentage, Career – 2.7
· [2nd] Most Passes without a Pass Interception – 190 (2006-07)
· [2nd] Highest Passer Rating, Season – 104.1 (2005)
· [Tied for 2nd] Most Passes Attempted, Game – 57 (at Houston, Sept. 12, 2010)
· [Tied for 2nd] Most Passes Completed, Rookie Game – 27 (at Baltimore, Nov. 29, 1998)
· [Tied for 2nd] Most Consecutive Completions – 17 (vs. Cleveland/at Tennessee, Sept. 25-Oct. 2, 2005); (vs. Denver/at Jacksonville, Dec. 13-17, 2009)
· [Tied for 2nd] Most Consecutive Games, 300 or More Passing Yards – 3 (2006, 2009)
· [Tied for 2nd] Most Touchdown Passes, Game – 5 (vs. Atlanta, Dec. 14, 2003; vs. Green Bay, Sept. 26, 2004; at Kansas City, Oct. 31, 2004; vs. Houston, Nov. 14, 2004)
· [3rd] Most Yards, Two Rushers – 1,825 (James 1,709/Manning 116, 2000)
· [3rd] Most Passes Attempted, Season – 575 (1998)
· [3rd] Most Passes Attempted, Game – 56 (at San Diego, Nov. 11, 2007)
· [3rd] Most Passes Attempted, Rookie Game – 52 (vs. New England, Nov. 1, 1998)
· [3rd] Most Passes Completed, Season – 392 (2002)
· [3rd] Most Passes Completed, Rookie Game – 26 (vs. N.Y. Jets, Nov. 15, 1998)
· [3rd] Most Consecutive Completions – 16 (at Tennessee, Oct. 11, 2009)
· [3rd] Most Consecutive Games with 20 or More Completions in a Game – 7 (2000-2001, 2002, 2005, 2006)
· [3rd] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Season – 67.3 (2005)
· [3rd] Most Passing Yards, Season – 4,500 (2009)
· [3rd] Most Passing Yards, Game – 433 (at Houston, Sept. 12, 2010)
· [3rd] Most Passing Yards, Rookie Game – 335 (at Seattle, Dec. 20, 1998)
· [3rd] Most Games, 300 or More Yards Passing, Season – 6 (2004, 2006)
· [3rd] Most Consecutive Games with a Touchdown Pass – 16 (2003-04)
· [3rd] Most Consecutive Games with Two or More Touchdown Passes – 8 (2005)
· [3rd] Highest Touchdown Percentage, Rookie Season – 4.52
· [3rd] Highest Touchdown Percentage, Game – 21.43 (at Detroit, Nov. 25, 2004)
· [3rd] Highest Passing Average Per Attempt, Season– 9.17 (2004)
· [3rd] Longest Pass, Rookie Season – 78t (to Marshall Faulk vs. New Orleans, Sept. 27, 1998)
· [3rd] Highest Passer Rating, Rookie Season – 71.2 (1998)
· [Tied for 3rd] Most Passes Completed, Game – 37 (vs. Tennessee, Nov. 3, 2002)
· [Tied for 3rd] Most Games with a Touchdown Pass, Season – 13 (2009)
· [Tied for 3rd] Highest Touchdown Percentage, Rookie Game – 10.00 (at San Francisco, Oct. 18, 1998)
· [Tied for 3rd] Most Passing Interceptions, Season – 23 (2001)
Postseason Records
· [1st] Most Passes Attempted, Career – 718
· [1st] Most Passes Attempted, Games – 48 (vs. San Diego, Jan. 13, 2008)
· [1st] Most Passes Completed, Career – 453
· [1st] Most Passes Completed, Game – 33 (vs. San Diego, Jan. 13, 2008)
· [Tied for 1st] Most Games – 19
· [1st] Most Passing Yards, Career – 5,389
· [1st] Most Passing Yards, Game – 458 (Denver, Jan. 9, 2005)
· [1st] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Career – 63.1
· [1st] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Game – 84.6 (vs. Denver, Jan. 4, 2004)
· [1st] Most Touchdown Passes, Career – 29
· [1st] Most Touchdown Passes, Game – 5 (vs. Denver, Jan. 4, 2004)
· [1st] Most Passes Intercepted, Career – 19
· [1st] Most Passes Intercepted, Game – 4 (at New England, Jan. 18, 2004)
· [1st] Longest Pass Play – 87t (to Brandon Stokley vs. Denver, Jan. 4, 2004)
· [2nd] Most Passes Attempted, Games – 47 (at New England, Jan. 18, 2004; vs. New England, Jan. 21, 2007)
· [2nd] Most Passes Completed, Game – 31 (vs. New Orleans, Feb. 7, 2010)
· [2nd] Most Passing Yards, Game – 402 (vs. San Diego, Jan. 13, 2008)
· [2nd] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Game – 81.8 (vs. Denver, Jan. 9, 2005)
· [2nd] Most Touchdown Passes, Game – 4 (vs. Denver, Jan. 9, 2005)
· [Tied 2nd] Most Passes Intercepted, Game – 3 (vs. Kansas City, Jan. 6, 2007)
· [3rd] Most Passes Attempted, Games – 45 (vs. New Orleans, Feb. 7, 2010)
· [3rd] Most Passes Completed, Game – 30 (vs. Kansas City, Jan. 7, 2007; vs. Baltimore, Jan. 16, 2010)
· [3rd] Most Passing Yards, Game – 377 (vs. Denver, Jan. 4, 2004; vs. N.Y. Jets, Jan. 24, 2010)
· [3rd] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Game – 78.9 (vs. Kansas City, Jan. 6, 2007)
· [3rd] Most Touchdown Passes, Game – 3 (at Kansas City, Jan. 11, 2004; vs. San Diego, Jan. 13, 2008; vs. N.Y. Jets, Jan. 24, 2010)
· [3rd] Longest Pass Play – 72t (to Reggie Wayne at San Diego, Jan. 3, 2009)
· [Tied for 3rd] Most Rushing Touchdowns, Career – 3
Broncos records held by Peyton
(Records through the 2015 season, Peyton’s final season with Denver)
· [1st] Most Yards Total Offense, Season – 5,446 (2013)
· [1st] Most Yards Passing, Season – 5,477 (2013)
· [1st] Best Winning Percentage as a Starting Quarterback – .793 (46-12)
· [1st] Most Passes Attempted, Season – 659 (2013)
· [1st] Most Passes Completed, Season – 450 (2013)
· [1st] Most Passes Completed, Game – 39 (vs. Tennessee, Dec. 8, 2013)
· [1st] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Career – 66.5
· [1st] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Season – 68.6 (2012)
· [1st] Most Touchdown Passes, Season – 55 (2013)
· [1st] Most Touchdown Passes, Game – 7 (vs. Baltimore, Sept. 5, 2013)
· [1st] Highest Average Gain Per Passing Attempt, Career – 7.89
· [1st] Highest Career Passer Rating – 101.7
· [1st] Highest Passer Rating, Season – 115.1 (2013)
· [1st] Most Consecutive Game with a Touchdown Pass – 44 (2012-14)
· [Tied for 1st] Most Passes Attempted, Game – 59 (vs. Tennessee, Dec. 8, 2013)
· [2nd] Most Passes Completed, Career – 1,443
· [2nd] Most Yards Total Offense, Career – 17,057
· [2nd] Most Yards Passing, Career – 17,112
· [2nd] Most Yards Passing, Season – 4,727 (2014)
· [2nd] Most Yards Passing, Game – 479 (vs. Arizona, Oct. 5, 2014)
· [2nd] Most Passes Attempted, Career – 2,170
· [2nd] Most Passes Completed, Season – 400 (2012)
· [2nd] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Season – 68.3 (2013)
· [2nd] Most Touchdown Passes, Career – 140
· [2nd] Most Touchdown Passes, Season – 39 (2014)
· [2nd] Highest Passer Rating, Season – 105.8 (2012)
· [2nd] Most Consecutive Passes without an Interceptions – 226 (2012-13)
· [Tied for 2nd] Most Touchdown Passes, Game – 5 (at Kansas City, Dec. 1, 2013; at Oakland, Nov. 9, 2014)
· [3rd] Most Yards Total Offense, Season – 4,703 (2014)
· [3rd] Most Yards Total Offense, Game – 477 (vs. Arizona, Oct. 5, 2014)
· [3rd] Most Yards Passing, Season – 4,659 (2012)
· [3rd] Most Passes Completed, Season – 395 (2014)
· [3rd] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Game– 89.3 (at Oakland, Dec. 29, 2013)
· [3rd] Most Touchdown Passes, Season – 37 (2012)
· [3rd] Highest Average Gain Per Passing Attempt, Season – 8.31 (2013)
· [Tied for 3rd] Most Passes Attempted, Game – 57 (at St. Louis, Nov. 16, 2014)
Postseason Records
· [1st] Most Passes Attempted, Game – 49 (vs. Seattle, Feb. 2, 2014)
· [1st] Most Passes Completed, Game – 34 (vs. Seattle, Feb. 2, 2014)
· [1st] Most Passing Yards, Game – 400 (vs. New England, Jan. 19, 2014)
· [Tied for 1st] Most Touchdown Passes, Game – 3 (vs. Baltimore, Jan. 12, 2013 – 2 OT)
· [2nd] Most Yards Total Offense, Career – 1,957
· [2nd] Most Yards Total Offense, Game – 399 (vs. New England, Jan. 19, 2014)
· [2nd] Most Passes Attempted, Career – 309
· [2nd] Most Passes Completed, Career – 196
· [2nd] Most Passes Completed, Game – 32 (vs. New England, Jan. 19, 2014)
· [2nd] Most Passing Yards, Career – 1,950
· [2nd] Most Touchdown Passes, Career – 11
· [2nd] Most Touchdown Passes, Game – 2 (vs. New England, Jan. 24, 2016; vs. New England, Jan. 19, 2014; vs. San Diego, Jan. 12, 2014)
· [2nd] Most Passes Intercepted, Career – 6
· [2nd] Best Interception Avoidance Percentage, Career – 01.9
· [3rd] Most Passes Attempted, Game – 46 (vs. Indianapolis, Jan. 11, 2015)
· [3rd] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Career – 63.4
· [3rd] Highest Pass Completion Percentage, Game – 74.4 (vs. New England, Jan. 19, 2014)
· [3rd] Highest Passer Rating, Game – 118.4 (vs. New England, Jan. 19, 2014)
· [Tied for 3rd] Most Passes Intercepted, Game – 2 (vs. Seattle, Feb. 2, 2014; vs. Baltimore, Jan. 12, 2013 – 2 OT)
League/Team Statistical Titles
NFL Statistical Championships
- Passing Titles: 2004, 2005, 2006
- Passing TD Titles: 2004, 2006, 2013
AFC Statistical Championships
- Passing Titles: 1999, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2012, 2013
- Passing TD Titles: 1999, 2000, 2003, 2004, 2006, 2009, 2012, 2013
Team Statistical Championships
Passing Yardage Titles: 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2012 DEN, 2013 DEN, 2014 DEN
DEN Denver Broncos All other titles won with Indianapolis Colts
- 2003 Associated Press Most Valuable Player
- 2004 Associated Press Most Valuable Player
- 2004 Associated Press Offensive Player of the Year
- 2005 Pro Bowl Player of the Game
- 2005 Walter Payton NFL Man of the Year
- Super Bowl XLI MVP
- 2008 Associated Press Most Valuable Player
- 2009 Associated Press Most Valuable Player
- 2012 Associated Press Comeback Player of the Year
- 2013 Associated Press Most Valuable Player
- 2013 Associated Press Offensive Player of the Year
- 2000s NFL All-Decade Team
Year-by-Year Team Records
1998 Indianapolis Colts............... 3-13-0 (5th)
1999 Indianapolis Colts............ 13-3-0 (1st)
2000 Indianapolis Colts............ 10-6-0 (2nd)
2001 Indianapolis Colts............... 6-10-0 (4th)
2002 Indianapolis Colts............ 10-6-0 (2nd)
2003 Indianapolis Colts............ 12-4-0 (1st)
2004 Indianapolis Colts............ 12-4-0 (1st)
2005 Indianapolis Colts............ 14-2-0 (1st)
2006 Indianapolis Colts............ 12-4-0 (1st)
2007 Indianapolis Colts............ 13-3-0 (1st)
2008 Indianapolis Colts............ 12-4-0 (2nd)
2009 Indianapolis Colts............ 14-2-0 (1st)
2010 Indianapolis Colts............ 10-6-0 (1st)
2011 Indianapolis Colts............... 2-14-0 (4th)
2012 Denver Broncos............... 13-3-0 (1st)
2013 Denver Broncos............... 13-3-0 (1st)
2014 Denver Broncos............... 12-4-0 (1st)
2015 Denver Broncos............... 12-4-0 (1st)