I don t want my sister in-law in my wedding

This bride's wedding party plans are a big old mess.

Writes Save the Date reader Ellis:

I feel bad even asking this, but do I have to ask my future sister-in-law, we'll call her Nichole, to be in my wedding party?

I think Nichole's sweet and we have a good relationship. I asked her two daughters to be my flower girls and was going to leave it at that, but now a cousin has asked Nichole to be in her wedding—so it feels awkward not to ask her to be in our wedding when I'm marrying her brother. I'm sure my groom expects me to ask her. But here are my concerns:

1. She's 10 years older than my friends and I. I don't think she'd enjoy hanging out with us—especially if the bachelorette party gets "inappropriate."

2. I feel like she'll be distracted on our wedding day, chasing after her daughters while the other bridesmaids are participating or having their pictures taken.

3. I was planning on having the bridesmaids and groomsmen sit together, but Nichole would probably want to sit with her family.

4. I feel like being a bridesmaid means being part of the group. Since Nichole has a new baby, I don't think she'll have time to help plan the shower and I don't think she'll have fun at the bachelorette party.

5. The bridesmaid dresses I picked out are fitted with a sweetheart neckline—and she's carrying a lot of post-baby weight. I'm NOT judging her. She is SuperMom! But I'm worried she'll feel obligated to say yes to my invite and then loathe me for asking her to wear a dress that won't flatter her.

6. My guy and I have put a "cap" on the number of people we can each ask to be in the wedding party. I hate to cut one of my lifelong girlfriends for the sake of including Nichole, who I'm just not that close with. My friends would be so hurt if I didn't ask them—but I'm not sure Nichole would even care if I don't ask her.

weddings

My parents have always taught me to be polite, that you should be kind and humble – but at what point do you stop? At what point do you say enough is enough?

There are two essential rules that my parents have bestowed upon me:

1. People don’t like to hear the truth.

There are many reasons for this rule. No one wants to hear that they are a bad person, or you don’t like them – sometimes you have pretend, you have to put your feelings aside and be mature in situations, for the benefit of everyone else.

2. You have to do things you don’t want to.

I don’t particularly enjoy cleaning the house but I have to do it . This rule also applies to socialising with people you may not like. Again, putting your feelings aside to avoid an argument and to satisfy others.

But please, someone explain to me, how long do you have to follow these rules? At what point can we just scream say, “OH MY GOD I can’t stand your selfish behaviour anymore!”

My sister-in-law is getting married in a matter of weeks.

In the build up to such event I would normally be organising my families outfits. If accommodation was required I would have organised it months in advance. I would be speaking to my children daily about the exciting event and even count down the days.

But I haven’t done anything for prepare myself or my family for this wedding. Why? Because, I honestly don’t care that she is getting married.

I don t want my sister in-law in my wedding
Image via iStock.

Leave a comment

I don t want my sister in-law in my wedding

Your Questions Answered

Hitched

I don t want my sister in-law in my wedding

I don t want my sister in-law in my wedding

Inside Gwyneth Paltrow's Morning Routine

You Beauty

Maybe I am a horrible person for saying that, but at what point do you start to care more about yourself then someone who frankly doesn’t like you?

I haven’t done anything to her to make her dislike me. I simply married her brother and have his children. I am a good mother, I have always been welcoming to her, I have gone out of my way to please her, to keep her updated in her nieces lives - but nothing seems to be good enough.

It is a relationship that requires too much effort. If she was my sister I would have told her to snap out of it, to step up and be a good auntie, to make an effort.

But she isn’t my sister, and it isn’t my place to say those things. I have to sit back and watch how she treats her entire family like dirt and somehow gets rewarded for this behaviour.

My children have no relationship with her, they don’t know anything about her and she lives in the same city as us. If we happen to see her at a family event she usually spends the entirety of the event on her phone, because god forbid you would want to have a relationship with your nieces.

Listen to Mamamia Out Loud: 'Til death do us part is over. Post continues after audio. 

Our eldest daughter started school this year, I thought, being in the same city as us she would come and see her off with us, she didn’t. She only messaged me to see how her first day went after she saw a post on my Instagram.

The only person we have met in her fiancé’s family is her fiancé, no family, no friends, no one. The only people we will know at her wedding will be our immediate family.

Is that normal?

The wedding is two hours away from where we live.

My husband has to take a day off work so we can attend - fuel, accomodation and naturally a gift. So, I asked what they would like as a gift, and was told: money.

How much money do you give to someone who has nothing to do with you, and only invited you to her wedding because we are related to her? We have kids and a mortgage we can’t afford to fork out hundreds of dollars for a wedding that will already cost us a small fortune to simply attend.

I don t want my sister in-law in my wedding
Image via iStock.

Honestly, if we had a close relationship we would do everything we could to give her an amazing gift. But we don’t, and I honestly don’t understand why we keep making effort when we get nothing in return. Giving her a few hundred dollars isn’t going to make her like me.

I have tried to make excuses for her in the past, but ultimately, it's just not fair.

I have been questioning everything, reliving the past to try and figure out what we did, but I cannot pin point it, she just doesn’t and I am mentally exhausted. Do I continue to pretend or just give up? How many times can you try to have a relationship with someone before you give up? Is there a breaking point? When is it ok to care more about yourself then others?

Have you ever been in this situation? Would you still go to the wedding?

Do you invite your siblings in laws to your wedding?

Yes, you should totally invite them to be bridesmaids and groomsmen. Most of the time, your wedding is about YOU. However, your future siblings in law are family – and even though you might not get along with them as amazingly well as you do with your BFF, you should still invite them in the wedding party.

Do you have to have your sister in your wedding?

There's no rule stating you absolutely must make your sister your maid of honor—or even include her in your bridal party at all.

Do I have to invite my sister in law?

It depends on why you don't want to invite her. If she's been hostile to you, it's understandable why you don't want to invite her, but if she's your brother's wife and you want to invite her brother, then you must invite her. If she's your fiance's sister or sister-in-law, you may have to invite her.

How do you deal with a wicked sister in law?

Maintain marital privacy. No matter how much your husband is deeply connected with his sister, after marriage, there needs a call for some privacy. ... .
Understand sibling bond. ... .
Involve your husband. ... .
Speak and make your point. ... .
Don't disrespect but withdraw. ... .
Do not entertain. ... .
Stay confident in your approach. ... .
Ask for help..