Which cluster is the youngest and which is the oldest?

How can the age of star clusters be determined? What is the difference between Main Sequence and Red Giant stars?

Índice Show

Star Clusters
Using H-R Diagrams to determine star cluster age
Which cluster is the oldest?
Which cluster has the oldest stars?
What is the youngest globular cluster?

In this video, Dr. Holger Baumgardt from the University of Queensland, helps explain age determination of star clusters using colour-magnitude diagrams and analysis.

Presenter: Dr. Holger Baumgardt 2012
Video Editor: Simon Boman 31 Jul 2013

Star Clusters

To add further background information on star clusters and determining their ages, we first need a little info on star clusters themselves - here is a clip from Crash Course Astronomy, by a Phil Plait from BadAstronomy.com.

Jewel Box cluster

Using H-R Diagrams to determine star cluster age

The age of star clusters can be estimated by examining a plot of star brightness (magnitude) against colour (temperature), this plot is known as a H-R diagram. Below are a few examples and variations of these plots.

Absolute magnitude vs Spectral class/Temperature (K)

Absolute magnitude vs Surface temperature (K)

Absolute magnitude vs B-V colour

The H-R diagram plot is used to reveal which stars are still on the main sequence - since we are able to easily identify how long a star is able to burn its hydrogen supply in its core before it moves onto the next stage of its lifecycle towards death. These are main-sequence lifespans and are easily found in tables (link 1) (link 2). You can google for more detailed tables with smaller intervals of temperature.

Note that in the upper left corner of the plot, the stars in this cluster have begun to peel away from the main sequence.

In the above example, we can see that the upper left stars have begun to move off the main sequence - hence they have moved onto the next stage of their life. This means

this star cluster

, has to have

aged long enough

for those few stars to have exceeded their main-sequence lifespan, but not old enough for the stars at about 0.5 B-V to have moved off main sequence.

Dr Baumgardt in the video above describes a process where they match the plots with defined 'isochrones' curves or plots (see diagram on the right), that are associated with a certain stellar age, however we can also make estimations based on this turning point on the graph.

The video below goes into more detail on the process of making an age estimation of star clusters.

An example of some of the isochrones that are used to match the star cluster plots.

Discussion:1)Which cluster is the oldest? How old?

Get answer to your question and much more

2)Which cluster is the youngest? How young?

Get answer to your question and much more

3)How do the ages of these star clusters compare with the age of the galaxy (or theage of the universe)? Comment on any differences.

Get answer to your question and much more

4)Which cluster is the most distant, and which is the closet? Comment on wherethese clusters tell us about the extent of the Milky Way galaxy.

Get answer to your question and much more

Introductory Astronomy

3rd EditionAbe Mizrahi, Edward E. Prather, Gina Brissenden, Jeff P. Adams

429 solutions

Astronomy

1st EditionAndrew Fraknoi, David Morrison, Sidney C Wolff

972 solutions

Foundations of Astronomy

11th EditionMichael A. Seeds

290 solutions

The Cosmic Perspective ( Edition)

8th EditionJeffrey O. Bennett, Mark Voit, Megan O. Donahue, Nicholas O. Schneider

1,638 solutions

Which cluster is the oldest?

A team of astronomers using the Gemini-South telescope has discovered one of the oldest stellar clusters in the Milky Way. The team's results date the globular cluster, named HP 1, at about 12.8 billion years, making its stars among the oldest ever found in our Galaxy.

Which cluster has the oldest stars?

Globular clusters contain several thousand to one million stars in spherical, gravitationally-bound system. Located mostly in the halo surrounding the galactic plane they comprise the oldest stars in the galaxy.